An agency can commit to agreed work or remedies, but cannot guarantee a specific organic recommendation from ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Google AI. Technical and content work can affect eligibility and available information, but results vary. Ask for defined work, test prompts, platform, reporting period and measures. Paid ads are sponsored placements, not organic recommendations.
An agency can commit to agreed deliverables or contractual remedies, but cannot guarantee or dictate that ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Google AI will return a specific organic recommendation for a South African business. Technical and content work can affect eligibility and the information available to a platform, but answers vary. A provider can report how results from a fixed test set change over time.
Disclosure: IDJoy sells AI search visibility services. This guide compares provider promises with public platform documentation. It does not rank agencies or claim that a particular vendor has made a misleading promise.
Updated 4 November 2026: Clarified the difference between guaranteed work and platform outcomes, and added checks for paid placements, publisher partnerships and proposal evidence.
What can an AI visibility provider control?
A provider can review whether public pages load, explain services and locations, present evidence, and allow the relevant crawlers. It can publish agreed changes and record how a fixed prompt set performs on named products and dates.
A provider cannot dictate which pages a platform will return, cite or rank for a particular test. Google says a page can meet its requirements and still not be crawled, indexed or served in its generative AI features. (OpenAI crawler guidance, Google AI features guidance)
Can a provider guarantee a ChatGPT recommendation?
OAI-SearchBot is OpenAI’s search crawler. Allowing it in a site’s robots.txt lets it access public pages for ChatGPT Search and makes the site eligible to appear; it does not reserve a recommendation. Blocking it keeps a site out of search answers, although navigational links may still appear. (OpenAI ChatGPT Search guidance, OpenAI crawler guidance)
OpenAI Ads are a separate product. OpenAI says ads are clearly labelled and separate from ChatGPT’s answers. Its October 2026 expansion included South Africa, with advertisers accessing campaigns through technology partners or Ads Manager. An ad is a sponsored placement, not an organic recommendation. (OpenAI Ads expansion, OpenAI ad system)
Ask the provider to state whether it means organic search visibility or a paid placement. The contract should name the deliverables and measurements for either service.
What does “number one in AI search” mean?
There is no shared cross-platform position called “number one in AI search.” Google says AI Overviews and AI Mode can return different responses and links. OpenAI says ChatGPT search placement is not guaranteed. A screenshot from one prompt, product mode, account and date cannot establish a permanent position across other conditions. (Google AI features guidance, OpenAI ChatGPT Search guidance)
Ask the provider to define:
- Which exact prompts and platforms it will test.
- Which product mode, account state and location it will use.
- What counts as a result: a business mention, citation, referral visit or qualified enquiry, using qualification criteria you agree in advance.
- How often it repeats the tests and how it handles changed answers.
If a proposal says “number one,” require the test conditions and underlying records before treating the claim as measurable.
Is a paid placement the same as organic inclusion?
OpenAI describes ChatGPT Ads as sponsored placements separate from the answers. Perplexity describes its Publisher Program as a partnership for publishers that includes advertising revenue sharing and product support. Neither description promises that paying an agency will make a small business rank first in organic answers. (OpenAI Ads expansion, Perplexity Publisher Program)
Ask the provider to name the product or partnership, who can apply, what gets displayed, whether the placement is labelled, what it costs and what reporting you receive. Ask for a link to the platform’s own terms. Treat “paid inclusion” as an unverified claim until the provider shows the specific route and explains what it buys.
Crawler access, sitemaps, structured data and business profiles help manage or describe public information. Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools provide site-management and search-reporting tools. None of these guarantees a specific AI answer.
What does a proprietary AI score prove?
A private score can help track work if the provider shows how it is calculated. It does not prove a platform ranking by itself.
For example, a score might combine prompts that use the business name with category searches that do not, plus mentions, citations, crawler visits and referral traffic. Those measures describe different things. Ask for:
- The formula and weights.
- The prompts, products and modes tested.
- Test dates and conditions.
- Raw answer records and cited URLs.
- Missing observations and repeat-test variation.
- Which results connect to visits, enquiries or sales.
Google warns against third-party tools that claim access to internal Google metrics. Use scores as a summary of disclosed observations, not as proof of privileged platform data. (Google generative AI search guide)
Does an llms.txt file make AI engines find your business?
Google Search does not use llms.txt for inclusion or ranking. Google says businesses may maintain the file for other services, but it will not help or harm their Google Search visibility. (Google generative AI search guide)
Perplexity’s documentation site links to an llms.txt file as an index for its own documentation. That example shows how one service organises its docs; it does not show that adding the file to a business website earns recommendations. (Perplexity crawler documentation)
Before paying for this work, ask which named platform uses the file, what information it reads from it and how the provider will verify that use. Compare the fee with that specific task and its stated deliverables.
Can schema help AI interpret a page?
Google’s generative AI search guide says there is no special schema markup required for its AI features. Google’s structured data documentation says markup gives Search explicit clues about page meaning and can make a page eligible for rich results; eligibility does not guarantee that Google will show one. (Google AI search guide, Google structured data guidance)
Ask to review the visible page alongside the markup. The text, prices, service areas and examples should match. Structured data describes page information; it does not supply missing evidence.
Is publishing 100 AI articles a month a sound plan?
Google’s AI search guide, last updated 10 July 2026, warns against creating separate pages for every query variation when the purpose is to manipulate rankings or AI responses. It also says a high page count does not make a site more useful or relevant. The policy concerns purpose and value, not a universal monthly article limit. (Google generative AI search guide)
A fixed publishing quota tells you how much content the agency plans to produce. It does not explain whether those pages answer distinct customer questions. Ask which business decision each article supports, what first-hand information it uses, and which existing page it complements.
Can an agency build authority without your input?
Public research can verify published facts. Your team holds details about project decisions, constraints, service delivery and approved examples that may not appear online.
Ask how the provider gathers that information, who checks factual claims, and whether your team approves case-specific material before publication. If no one supplies or verifies first-hand details, the writer should stay within sources that readers can inspect.
Does an AI mention prove revenue?
A business mention does not show whether someone clicked, enquired or bought. Ask the provider to report each observation separately:
- The prompt, product and date tested.
- Whether the business appeared and whether a page was cited.
- Any referral visit recorded in analytics.
- Enquiries and sales that the business can connect to those visits.
An attribution report can show a path, but the report alone cannot establish that an AI answer caused a sale. Agree on the records available before the campaign starts.
Can an agency make AI visibility permanent?
AI answers and links can change. Google says its AI Search features can vary, and OpenAI does not guarantee ChatGPT search placement. A contract should describe the test schedule, prompt set, content updates, error corrections, reporting limits and what happens when a result changes. (Google AI features guidance, OpenAI crawler guidance)
Ask what the provider will still deliver if an answer, citation or referral disappears.
What should an AI visibility proposal include?
Before signing, ask for a written scope that states:
- Which platforms, product modes and prompts the provider will test.
- How prompts were selected, including customer searches, and whether the complete prompt set and results will be shared.
- Which technical and content changes are included.
- How it will gather and verify your business evidence.
- Itemised fees for setup, implementation, content and ongoing measurement.
- Delivery dates and any work that depends on your team or another supplier.
- Raw answer records, citation URLs and limits on the reporting.
- Which accounts and published material you own.
- How the provider handles corrections, cancellation and handover.
- Whether reports separate organic answers from paid placements and show how mentions, citations, referrals, enquiries and sales are counted.
Compare proposals by their included deliverables, exclusions and evidence rather than by a single score or article count.
What IDJoy can promise
We can scope work on crawler access, site structure, service information, original evidence, internal links, business-fact consistency and a repeatable prompt set. The proposal should state which items it includes and how we will report them.
We can commit to agreed deliverables, but cannot guarantee an organic recommendation, first position, fixed date or permanent visibility. Review IDJoy’s AI search visibility service, how to measure AI recommendations and how to improve AI search visibility before comparing proposals.