Run the same 20 buyer questions in ChatGPT Search, Gemini, Perplexity Search and Google AI Search features. Record the product settings, location, business mentions, factual accuracy and cited or related sources. Compare results within each product over time; the products expose different features and do not share one comparable ranking.
A search for a business by name records what that product returns for that query. A buyer who asks for a provider in a service category may get a different result.
Updated 4 November 2026: Clarified how to compare product-specific results and what current AI search reporting can show.
This guide helps South African small-business owners check whether ChatGPT Search, Gemini, Perplexity Search and Google’s AI Search features describe their business accurately. Run the same 20 buyer questions in each product, record its settings and sources, then compare each product with its own earlier results.
What should a cross-product visibility check measure?
Check whether a product names the business for a relevant customer question, gets the service and location right, and provides sources or a route a customer can use. A branded query shows what that product returned for the business name in that run.
ChatGPT Search may run automatically or when you select Search; Gemini Apps may show related sources on some answers; Perplexity Search has different search features; Google AI Overviews and AI Mode are separate Google Search experiences. Their modes and settings differ. OpenAI’s Search guide, Gemini’s source guide and Google’s AI features guidance describe those product-specific behaviors.
Use the 20-prompt baseline sheet
The free 20-prompt baseline sheet below contains buyer questions grouped around service, location, comparison and trust. Replace bracketed text with accurate business details, then keep each prompt unchanged between runs. Use a new conversation for each prompt. If a product surface is unavailable in your region or account, record that instead of substituting a different feature without noting it.
Examples from the sheet:
- “Who can solve [specific problem] in South Africa?”
- “Provider serving Pretoria.”
- “Compare three providers for [service] in [city].”
- “Which [business category] has strong case studies?”
For comparisons, name real providers only when you have a reason to compare them. Ask for sources and mark missing information rather than treating an unsupported detail as fact. The same business may be mentioned, cited or offered differently across products and prompts.
Record the conditions and result
For each run, record:
- Date, product and exact surface, such as ChatGPT Search, Gemini Apps, Perplexity Search, Google AI Overviews or Google AI Mode.
- Exact prompt, country or location, language, account state, selected model and search mode where the product exposes them.
- Whether the product named the business, what it said about the service and location, and whether those facts were correct.
- Whether citations or related sources appeared, the exact URLs, and whether those pages support the answer.
- Whether the response offered a useful next step, such as a working service page or contact route.
Save the answer text or a screenshot if useful for the next comparison. In Gemini, record when no Sources option appears; Google says not all Gemini responses include related sources. In ChatGPT, confirm that web Search was used. For other products, note the selected search mode and model when available.
What does each product’s evidence tell you?
ChatGPT Search responses may include citations, and search can start automatically or be selected from the tools menu. Open cited pages to confirm that they support the answer; OpenAI warns that search results and citations can be incomplete, outdated or incorrect. See OpenAI’s Search instructions.
Gemini Apps sometimes shows a Sources panel with related pages. Google says a response may have no Sources option. Treat that as “no source links shown in this response,” not proof that Gemini could not access a particular site. See Gemini’s source guide.
Perplexity describes its product as a web-search service that returns conversational answers with citations. Record the exact Search feature and model because its modes and model options can differ. See Perplexity’s product guide.
Google AI Overviews and AI Mode are features within Google Search, not names for every Google AI product. Google says pages must meet ordinary Search technical requirements to be eligible as supporting links; inclusion is not guaranteed. Its guidance requires no separate AI schema or special AI text file. Read Google’s AI features guidance.
Separate missing mentions from access problems
A missing mention does not show why the product omitted the business. It could reflect the query, the product’s available search mode, location or account context, source selection, or missing and conflicting public information. Check that the product searched the web before treating the result as a visibility test.
If a useful page appears inaccessible, check it separately. Ask your developer or host: “Does robots.txt allow OAI-SearchBot, and do the server or content delivery network (CDN) logs show blocked requests from OpenAI’s published IP ranges?” Check the page status as well. For ChatGPT Search, OpenAI says OAI-SearchBot is used to surface websites in search results and recommends allowing it in robots.txt and allowing requests from its published IP ranges. OAI-SearchBot and GPTBot have different purposes and controls. Check OpenAI’s current crawler documentation.
Compare business facts across the website and public profiles the business manages. Check the service offered, real service area, contact details and working enquiry route. Correct conflicting or outdated details at the source.
If competitor pages appear in citations, inspect the exact pages. They may explain a product’s answer, but one result does not establish a ranking factor or prove that a competitor is universally preferred. Add accurate service details and verifiable project evidence where those are missing; do not manufacture reviews, links or claims.
Check referrals separately from mentions
A mention is not a visit or a qualified enquiry. Check analytics for identifiable referral visits where the platform and your analytics setup expose them. Compare those visits with page activity and enquiries, while accounting for visitors who return through another channel or are not attributed to an AI product.
Google’s Search Console Generative AI performance report covers impressions for links shown in AI Overviews and AI Mode. It groups data by page, country, date or device, and Google says the report may be unavailable when a site has too few impressions. The report does not show the exact prompts people entered. It is a separate measurement from your own 20-prompt checks. Read the current report details.
Repeat the check when something changes
Repeat the same prompts within each product after correcting business facts, changing service pages or fixing a verified access problem. Keep the date and product settings so you can see what changed. Choose a review interval that matches how often your services, public information or site changes.
Joy Mahlatjie is IDJoy’s founder and the author of this guide. IDJoy offers AI search visibility services. Review the service scope and pricing before deciding whether you need outside help.