A legitimate affiliate programme should explain the product, work, commission calculation, payment trigger and business behind the offer. Be cautious when you must pay to join, recruit people to recover your money, buy stock, surrender an OTP or banking PIN, accept guaranteed-income claims, or share a link without disclosing that you may earn commission.
People searching for extra income are easy targets for offers that use urgency, shame or financial pressure to stop them asking basic questions.
A professional-looking website does not prove that an earning opportunity is safe. A WhatsApp testimonial does not prove that most members earn money. A screenshot of a bank balance does not explain where the money came from.
The useful test is simpler: can you identify the real business, understand the work, calculate the commission and explain exactly what must happen before payment?
Disclosure: IDJoy runs the partner programme used as an example in this article. Compare its current terms on the IDJoy partner programme page. The warning signs below apply to any provider.
Updated 4 November 2026: Added the publisher disclosure, clarified section 43 and replaced an unsupported social-platform claim with current official guidance.
Red flag 1: you must pay to join
A joining fee alone does not answer whether a programme meets the Act’s definition of a pyramid scheme. Section 43 of South Africa’s Consumer Protection Act looks at whether participants’ compensation comes mainly from recruiting other participants rather than selling goods or services, or whether the scheme is promoted that way. Ask what a fee pays for and how the programme earns its revenue. Read section 43 of the Act before treating a fee as proof either way.
Be cautious when the payment is described as:
- an activation fee;
- a starter package;
- compulsory training;
- a licence to begin earning;
- a higher level that unlocks serious income; or
- a once-off payment you will quickly recover by recruiting others.
A referral programme should explain any joining cost, what it buys and whether it is optional before you sign up.
Red flag 2: recruitment matters more than the service
Ask what the end customer buys.
A normal referral programme pays because a customer bought a real service or product. A recruitment-led scheme focuses on bringing more participants into the earning structure.
Warning signs include:
- commission for recruiting partners rather than customers;
- pressure to recruit a chain of new members;
- earnings diagrams dominated by member levels;
- little evidence of ordinary customers buying the underlying service; and
- advice to approach friends and family before you understand the offer.
Section 43 focuses on how participant compensation is generated. Ask for written terms that show whether a reward comes from customer sales or from recruiting participants.
Red flag 3: guaranteed or effortless income
No honest referral programme can guarantee that a business will buy.
The business may already have a supplier, lack budget, delay the project or decide that the service is not suitable. Even a strong introduction can fail to close.
Treat phrases such as these with caution:
- guaranteed weekly income;
- earn while doing nothing;
- copy and paste this link for daily cash;
- financial freedom in thirty days;
- no skills, time or effort required; and
- everybody succeeds if they follow the system.
Referral work can be flexible, but it is still work. You need judgement, context and a useful introduction.
Red flag 4: the commission cannot be calculated
A credible programme should answer:
- What percentage or fixed amount applies?
- Which project value is used?
- Does VAT form part of the calculation?
- When is the rate fixed?
- Can the rate change after the sale?
- What happens when a client receives a refund or the project is cancelled?
- When does commission move from estimated to payable?
Be careful when earnings are described only with exceptional screenshots or phrases such as “up to R50,000” without showing the ordinary calculation.
Before joining, check the written terms for the rate, calculation base, VAT treatment, qualifying event, cancellations and payment timing. IDJoy publishes its current rates and prices on its partner programme page; its separate guide explains when referral commission is paid.
Red flag 5: there is no attribution record
A referral programme needs a fair way to answer: who introduced the client?
Without a referral code, link, project record or timestamp, the business can later say that it cannot prove where the lead came from.
A solid system should show:
- your unique referral identity;
- the introduction you submitted;
- the client company or reference;
- the current status;
- duplicate handling;
- the commission calculation when applicable; and
- payout information after payment.
For any programme, ask how the referral is connected to your account and what record you can check if a claim is disputed. Do not rely on a technical promise that is missing from the written terms.
Red flag 6: you are told to hide the commission
People are more likely to distrust a recommendation when they discover later that it was paid.
Disclose the relationship clearly. For example:
“I am part of IDJoy’s referral programme and may earn commission if the company chooses to work with them.”
Disclosure does not weaken a relevant recommendation. It shows that you respect the person making the decision.
Place the disclosure beside the recommendation or link. If you post on social media, check that platform’s rules and the Advertising Regulatory Board’s current Code of Advertising Practice. Its Social Media Code requires paid social advertising that could look like an unsolicited opinion to be clearly identified as advertising.
Red flag 7: private financial information is requested through chat
A legitimate payment process does not require your banking PIN or one-time password.
In July 2026, SARS said it will never ask for passwords, one-time pins (OTPs), banking PINs or eFiling login credentials through email, SMS, social media or telephone. eFiling is SARS’s online tax service. Use a SARS contact route reached from its official website if you need to check a message. Apply the same caution to earning programmes.
Do not send these through WhatsApp, direct message or email:
- online-banking password;
- card PIN;
- banking-app approval code;
- OTP;
- eFiling password; or
- a photograph that exposes unnecessary identity or card information.
IDJoy partners enter payout details after signing in to the partner portal. Reach the portal from idjoy.co.za and use the site’s published contact route if a request looks unusual. No programme should need your banking PIN, card PIN or OTP to pay commission.
Red flag 8: there is no real business to contact
Check whether the programme shows:
- the registered or trading business name;
- a working company domain;
- a business email address;
- examples of the real service;
- clear terms or programme explanations;
- a privacy route; and
- a way to raise a question with a person.
A social-media profile alone is easier to replace or abandon than an established business presence.
Red flag 9: pressure replaces explanation
Scam pressure often sounds like:
- register before midnight;
- the opportunity is closing permanently;
- borrow the joining fee;
- do not discuss it with negative people;
- your questions show that you lack the right mindset; or
- move the conversation away from the official platform.
A legitimate programme should allow you to read, compare and decline.
A ten-question check before joining
Ask these questions in writing:
- What does the customer buy?
- Who delivers it?
- Do I pay anything?
- Do I earn from recruiting other participants?
- How is my introduction recorded?
- What makes a referral duplicate?
- What event makes commission payable?
- What records will I receive?
- How are banking details protected?
- Who can I contact when a status looks wrong?
Unclear answers are information. Do not let urgency force you to ignore them.
Common questions
Does a joining fee automatically make a programme illegal?
No. A fee alone does not answer that question. Section 43 looks at whether participant compensation comes mainly from recruiting other participants instead of selling goods or services, and at how the scheme is promoted. Get independent advice if you need a legal assessment.
What should I check before sharing a referral link?
Read the commission and payment terms, confirm how the referral is tracked, and disclose any commission next to your recommendation. Check the platform’s current promotion rules before posting.
Is referral commission taxable in South Africa?
SARS lists commission among the income that can be taxable. The tax due depends on your circumstances. Keep your payment records and check your position with SARS or a tax practitioner.
Check the terms before you decide
This checklist helps you spot unanswered questions; it cannot certify a provider. Compare the answers with the programme’s written terms. For IDJoy’s current rate and rules, read the partner programme page and the guide to referral commission payments. Commission may affect your tax position; SARS explains who pays income tax. Check your own circumstances before treating a gross payment as take-home income.